Sarcone's Bakery
Bella Vista
4.7 / 5
The crust is the perfect balance of chewy and crunchy, and the sauce is the least marinara-like—just pure, crushed tomatoes.
Local LegendClassicMust-Try
Corropolese Italian Bakery & Deli
Suburban Philly
4.8 / 5
The tomato layer is paste- or jam-like in consistency and it's much sweeter than others. It's deeply addicting.
ClassicCrowd PleaserAward Winner
New York Bakery
South Philadelphia
4.9 / 5
A true gem. Zero web presence or social media. Cash only. Excellent tomato pie and the owner Steve is a genuinely nice person.
Hidden GemOld SchoolAuthentic
Gaeta's Tomato Pies
Northeast Philadelphia
4.8 / 5
These Northeast Philly pies are thick, crunchy and saucy without being overwhelming. Word is they're even better the next day.
Local LegendNeighborhood FavoriteCrunchy
Cacia's Bakery
South Philadelphia
4.6 / 5
The classic tomato pie is remarkably thin, barely half an inch at its thickest point, with a jammy tomato paste seasoned with oregano.
ClassicNostalgicOld School