Best Butter Tarts in Toronto, CA

An iconic Ontario pastry shell filled with a gooey mixture of butter, sugar, and eggs.

The Rolling Pin

North York

4.6 / 5

The crust is incredibly flaky and the filling has the perfect amount of ooze without being messy.

Award WinningLocal LegendInstagrammable

9.8Flavor

8.2Value

8.7Vibe

Etobicoke

4.7 / 5

A hidden gem in Etobicoke. The jazz music and the smell of fresh tarts make it a perfect experience.

Hidden GemClassicArtisanal

9.5Flavor

8.5Value

9.2Vibe

Leslieville

4.8 / 5

The best butter tarts in the East End. The filling is dark, rich, and perfectly caramelized.

Local LegendMust-TryClassic

9.4Flavor

8Value

7.8Vibe

West Queen West

4.4 / 5

Consistent and delicious. It's the gold standard for a traditional, no-fuss butter tart.

Local FavoriteClassicReliable

8.9Flavor

8.4Value

8.5Vibe