Best Black and White Cookie in New York, NY

A soft, cake-like cookie glazed with vanilla fondant on one half and chocolate on the other.

William Greenberg Desserts

Upper East Side

4.5 / 5

The gold standard of black and whites... perfectly soft and cakey with a signature chocolate-vanilla fondant.

Local LegendClassicGold StandardSeinfeld Approved

9.8Flavor

7.2Value

8.5Vibe

Lower East Side

4.7 / 5

A taste of old New York. Big, balanced, and something of a bargain for the quality you receive.

IconicClassicTourist FavoriteHistoric

9.1Flavor

8.5Value

9.6Vibe

Upper East Side

4.4 / 5

Truly the epitome of a black and white cookie. The soft cakey dough is very nice and moist.

Local LegendClassicArtisanalNeighborhood Staple

9.3Flavor

7.5Value

8.7Vibe