Mairangi Bay Bakery
Mairangi Bay
4.8 / 5
Widely considered the gold standard in New Zealand, this square is famous for its structural integrity and the perfect ratio of creamy, firm custard to crisp pastry.
Local LegendClassicAward Winning
Euro Patisserie Torbay
Torbay
4.7 / 5
A North Shore rival to Mairangi Bay, known for its sheer size and a custard that has a perfect 'wobble' without being too soft.
Hidden GemLocal LegendMassive Portions
This is the 'posh' version of the custard square, utilizing high-quality ingredients and a more rustic, handmade aesthetic.
InstagrammableArtisanGourmet
The Mustard Kitchen
Morningside
4.6 / 5
A masterclass in balance; the icing is delicately applied so it doesn't overpower the rich, dairy-forward flavor of the custard.
Hidden GemClassicNeighborhood Favorite